A Developer WeBLOG RSS 2.0

Many people say that building your own computer will give you the best bang of your buck. Is that really true? In this blog post I will be comparing a couple of intel based computer builds in comparison with Dell Australia’s current lineup. All the computer parts that I choose are based on my personal preferences and I will be using IJK online as a store choice. Please note that I’m not in any way affiliated with IJK or Dell.

Core i7 PC

 

IJK

Dell
Studio XPS

21.5” Widescreen LCD Monitor

$235

 

Computer Case with 420Watts PSU

$94

 

X58 Motherboard

$355

 

Intel Core i7 920

$475

 

3Gb DDR3 PC8500 (1066Mhz)

$94

 

500 GB HDD

$97

 

512MB ATI Radeon HD4850

$239

 

DVD with dual layer capabilities

$32

 

Internal Media Card Reader

$45

 

Generic keyboard and mouse

$22

 

Windows Vista Home Premium 64 bit

$175

 

Total Cost

$1,863

$1,999

 

Quad Core PC

 

IJK

Dell
XPS 430

21.5” Widescreen LCD Monitor

$235

 

Computer Case with 420Watts PSU

$94

 

X48 Motherboard

$290

 

Intel Core2Quad Q8200

$282

 

3Gb DDR3 PC8500 (1066Mhz)

$94

 

320 GB HDD

$79

 

512MB ATI Radeon HD4670

$129

 

DVD with dual layer capabilities

$32

 

Internal Media Card Reader

$45

 

Generic keyboard and mouse

$22

 

Windows Vista Home Premium 64 bit

$175

 

Total Cost

$1,477

$1,699

 

Dual Core PC

 

IJK

Dell
Studio Desktop

23” Widescreen LCD Monitor

$350

 

Computer Case with 420Watts PSU

$94

 

G45 Motherboard

$147

 

Intel Core2Duo E7400

$199

 

3Gb DDR2 PC6400 (800Mhz)

$90

 

320 GB HDD

$79

 

256MB ATI Radeon HD3450

$72

 

DVD with dual layer capabilities

$32

 

19 in 1 Media card reader with bluetooth

$45

 

Generic keyboard and mouse

$22

 

Windows Vista Home Premium 64 bit

$175

 

Total Cost

$1,305

$1,399

 

As you can see that building your computer is indeed cheaper, but the price difference is not really that much. The extra price that you pay for the Dell machine is for better warranty policy and customer service. With Dell offering free upgrades every week, I think that the price difference has become negligible. For example, sometimes you can get a free upgrade to 23” LCD monitor. The price difference between a 21.5” monitor and a 23” monitor is about $125, which is the difference between the Dell Studio XPS with the Core i7 build.

One problem with building a system is that, there is a chance of incompatibilities between components. Does this memory module work for this motherboard? Does this PSU has enough power for the whole system? When you are getting a premade system you do not have to worry with those kind of questions. Getting a premade system means that it is guaranteed to work. You also get the convenience of plugging a couple of cables and your system is ready to use. No hassle of assembling your system and no skin cuts too.

Building your own system has its benefit too. You can mix and match any components and choose components of best quality. Building your own system means you will get better quality components. I’m not saying that Dell has a subpar quality, but most likely that the components you get from dell would be generic value oriented components (probably not the case for XPS pcs). For example, in Dell machine, You will not get RAMs with heat spreader, You will not get high speed HDDs (not on default configuration), and most likely you will not get good efficient PSU. With better hardware you can push your system further by overclocking it, and that is a big plus for building your PC. You can still overclock a Dell (on certain models), but doing that will probably void your warranty.

I think when it comes to choosing whether to get a premade system or build your own, you should not really be worry about cost, as both option will virtually cost the same. It all comes down to your personal preference. The convenience of a premade system or the better quality of a ”build your own” system.

RWendi

Friday, February 20, 2009 11:08:06 AM UTC |  Comments [2]
Computer Hardware | General
Monday, August 10, 2009 9:16:15 PM UTC
It is always difficult to accurately compare the sum of a home build system with the price of a store bought computer. All the components would have to be identical. I have always built my own PC's, but I guess I do it because I like it :-)
Saturday, August 22, 2009 8:57:01 PM UTC
Spot on Aage, it is never easy to compare them. That's why I based the comparisons off the dell systems, and find similar components for the home build systems, so that I can always match off the components specification.

Btw, yeah building your own system is a lot more fun. The personal satisfaction of doing it, is priceless. :)
RWendi
OpenID
Please login with either your OpenID above, or your details below.
Name
E-mail
(will show your gravatar icon)
Home page

Comment (Some html is allowed: a@href@title, b, blockquote@cite, em, i, strike, strong, sub, sup, u) where the @ means "attribute." For example, you can use <a href="" title=""> or <blockquote cite="Scott">.  

Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

Live Comment Preview
All Content © 2012, RWendi